• RSS Feed
  • Subscriber Login
  • Weiss Ratings
Money and Markets
Skip to content
  • Home
  • Experts
    • Martin D. Weiss, Ph.D.
    • Jack Crooks
    • John Ross Crooks, III
    • Tom Essaye
    • Mike Larson
    • Nilus Mattive
    • Ron Rowland
    • Guest Contributors ►
      • Monty Agarwal
      • Sean Brodrick
      • Amber Dakar
      • Larry Edelson
      • Don Lucek
      • Rudy Martin
      • Tony Sagami
      • Peter Schiff
      • Claus Vogt
  • Blog
    • Martin D. Weiss’ Blog
    • Jack Crooks’ Blog
    • Mike Larson’s Blog
    • Nilus Mattive’s Blog
  • Resources
    • Personal Finance Corner ►
      • Hot Tips
      • Investments
      • Money & Banking
      • Consumer Loans
      • College Savings
      • Retirement
      • Credit & Debt
      • Taxes
      • Insurance
      • Life & Home
      • Investment Portfolios
    • Links
  • Services
    • Premium Membership Services  ►
      • Weiss Inner Circle
      • Money and Markets Inner Circle
      • The Weiss Elite
    • Trading Services ►
      • Global Forex Alert
      • International ETF Trader
      • LEAPS Options Alert
      • Million-Dollar Contrarian Portfolio
      • Safe Money’s Crisis Trader
      • Weiss Million-Dollar Ratings Portfolio
      • World Currency Trader
    • Investment Newsletters ►
      • Income Superstars
      • Safe Money
    • Books ►
      • The Ultimate Depression Survival Guide
      • Investing Without Fear
      • The Standard & Poor’s Guide for the New Investor
      • The Ultimate Safe Money Guide
    • Public Service
  • Media and Events
    • Press Releases
    • Money and Markets in the News
    • Media Archive ►
      • 2011 Media Archive
      • 2010 Media Archive
      • 2009 Media Archive
      • 2008 Media Archive
      • 2007 Media Archive
  • Issues
    • 2012 Issues
    • 2011 Archives
    • 2010 Archives
    • 2009 Archives
    • 2008 Archives
    • 2007 Archives
    • 2006 Archives
    • 2005 Archives
    • 2004 Archives
    • 2003 Archives
    • Special Reports
  • Videos
  • Store
  • Contact Us
    • Interview a Money and Markets Analyst
    • Reader’s Comments – Testimonials

Issues

Share Email Print

Sentiment Analysis: How Perception Drives Prices

Jack Crooks | Saturday, April 12, 2008 at 7:30 am

Jack Crooks

Topsy-turvy markets like these can easily make your head spin. I mean, we’re currently dealing with overdone trends, implosive fundamentals, government regulation and an increasingly globalized world economy.

And as if simply understanding those complex dynamics wasn’t enough, we still have the difficult task of trying to make money.

Often times, when there’s so much going on it makes sense to step back to a more basic approach — one grounded in human nature. This may actually be your best bet in making money in the long-run.

In this issue of Money and Markets, I want to focus on one key point that, if properly understood, may well increase your trading profits during the next eight months, and beyond. I’ll also tell you about two popular trading systems.

Let’s start with this simple premise …

Prices are Driven by the Ever-Changing
Perceptions of Buyers and Sellers

Conflicting ideas between traders exist at all times, everywhere. That’s why it is said that markets are grounded in human nature. And remember, it takes disagreement over value and price in order for a market to exist in the first place.

The following illustration is a perfect example of this tug-of-war playing out in the currency markets.

The U.S. dollar was suffering on Thursday morning … again … and breaking down below critical support levels.

But the price action was merely a head-fake, to suck in short sellers, before a sharp dollar rally that would knock them upside the head and force them to cover their shorts.

We’ve been presented with many similar situations in the past few years. And every time it seemed as though the dollar succumbed to market pressure and quickly pressed even lower.

But sure enough, the buck staged a mighty reversal this time.

Of course, it goes without saying now that some traders have been handed their losses, the dollar’s next leg lower is probably soon to come!

Internal Sponsorship

» Dollar plunges to new all-time low!
» Resources surge to new all-time highs!
» Huge profit potential now available!

With the U.S. dollar falling out of bed, copper, oil, corn, and wheat have just hit new all-time highs, resuming their big bull market, while gold and silver are on the same upward path!

So we can’t wait any longer: Major new resource recos are coming TUESDAY!

Get on board now or you could miss huge profits in this new phase of the great commodities super boom!

Click here for more information …

 

Rational? Of course not! But the turbulent price action in the dollar does sum up exactly the point I am attempting to get at …

Markets NEVER Behave Rationally

After so many years in the markets I’ve developed a few pet-peeves. At the top of that list is when I hear someone say “The markets are acting irrationally.”

Well of course they are. Markets never behave rationally — never. How can markets be rational when humans create markets and humans are irrational? Market prices are based on an expected future based on assumptions that are always flawed because the future cannot be forecasted. The best that can be said is that there are “degrees” of rationality in the market.

Some people seem to think that prices are event driven. In other words, economic releases and news events are always what cause prices to move the way they do. In actuality, the people who believe this are wrong.

For instance, if IBM were to report better-than-expected earnings, its share price will go up, right?

Not necessarily. Its share price may go up, but it also may go down!

The price action depends on how the players trading shares of IBM feel about the current earnings report, future earnings forecasts, current market environment, their personal financial situations and so on and so forth.

Traders and investors’ reactions to events and fundamentals drive prices. Real people move real money based on the difference between expectations and reality.

Without differing perceptions we could never have a dynamic market. And for that reason, strategies have been developed in hopes of harnessing these perceptions. One of them …

The Dow Theory:
Three Phases of Price Movements

Charles Henry Dow developed a series of principles for understanding and analyzing market behavior which later became known as Dow Theory.
Charles Henry Dow developed a series of principles for understanding and analyzing market behavior which later became known as Dow Theory.

The Dow Theory, as credited to Charles Dow, was created after a gathering and analysis of numerous editorials written by him, and further explained and improved upon by William Hamilton, and finally culminating in a book titled, The Dow Theory, written by Robert Rhea.

The Theory is made up of six major tenets. In an effort to explain the make-up of major trends within markets, one of these tenets outlined three phases of price movements within a primary trend. (The phases, as described below, refer to a primary uptrend.)

Phase #1 — Rebound and Accumulation

After a primary downtrend expires, enter the smart money. Beaten-down prices slowly recover and buying interest grows. The primary uptrend builds from this turning point.

Phase #2 — Public Participation

Fundamentals begin to brighten and investors begin to feel that prices need to go higher. The public gets in on the action and powers the uptrend. This accounts for the largest and most rapid change in price.

Phase #3 — Speculation

This is the last hurrah for the primary trend. At this point, the only thing driving prices higher are those investors giving too much credit to lackluster fundamentals. The speculators are left buying even when conditions aren’t necessarily improving.

The three phases make up basic stepping stones that help in understanding how investor sentiment drives prices. Charles Dow noticed that markets tend to move in an orderly fashion, repeating the same patterns over and over again.

External Sponsorship

Gold Explodes … $932 and climbing!
Special Report: 5 Ways to Play the Mega Metal Trend

Find out how you can snap up a “cheaper than a penny” gold producer with 100% upside potential … and how to get “zero-downside gold” with government-backed gains.

“I’m so sure gold will soar higher, we’ll even make you a guarantee … plus I’ll give you 5 new ways to play the trend …”

Learn how you can invest in gold without paying $932 per ounce. But you must act before April 15 or you’ll miss out completely.

Click here for the full free report, offer ends April 15 …

 

But Dow wasn’t the only market follower who attempted to dissect the role of sentiment on markets. Ralph Nelson Elliot sought to develop a systematic approach to analyze investor attitude.

Elliot and His Wave Theory

The process Elliot developed would eventually be known as Elliot Wave. And while a perfect understanding of Elliot Wave is complicated, there are a few simple ideas that can guide you in analyzing market sentiment.

First, there are impulse and corrective waves that make up a trend. Impulse waves steer the trend, i.e. they move in the same direction as the primary trend. Corrective waves are a response to impulse waves and retrace pieces of the trend, i.e. they move against the primary trend.

Second, these impulse and corrective waves typically join together to produce a 5-wave pattern. Now, I’m not going to force-feed you the monotonous information required to understand wave construction and formation, but I do want to visually share with you the most basic 5-wave pattern.

Basic 5-wave pattern

In this basic pattern you can also find the three phases described in Dow Theory as I mentioned earlier. I’ve overlaid them on the same basic 5-wave pattern in the following graphic:

Dow Theory

Needless to say, there’s something to this. But again, I want to drive home the point that however complicated all this technical analysis might appear, it’s all based on human nature. In fact …

In the Endgame, Understanding
Investor Attitudes Is Critical

I firmly believe that keeping a pulse on investor attitude is hugely important. Perhaps more important than knowing how much profit Google reeled in for the fourth quarter, or exactly the rate at which the Japanese economy grew in 2007.

So how does all this apply to the turbulent price action we witnessed in the U.S. dollar this past week? Well, I tend to believe we’re very near a critical turning point.

Dow Theory

Let me leave you with this weekly chart of the U.S. Dollar Index. This chart captures the most recent major down leg of the dollar bear market that began all the way back in 2002. Is ‘Wave 5′ close to wrapping up? It sure looks like it to me!

Best wishes,

Jack



About Money and Markets

For more information and archived issues, visit http://www.moneyandmarkets.com

Money and Markets (MaM) is published by Weiss Research, Inc. and written by Martin D. Weiss along with Tony Sagami, Nilus Mattive, Sean Brodrick, Larry Edelson, Michael Larson and Jack Crooks. To avoid conflicts of interest, Weiss Research and its staff do not hold positions in companies recommended in MaM, nor do we accept any compensation for such recommendations. The comments, graphs, forecasts, and indices published in MaM are based upon data whose accuracy is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Performance returns cited are derived from our best estimates but must be considered hypothetical in as much as we do not track the actual prices investors pay or receive. Regular contributors and staff include Kristen Adams, Andrea Baumwald, John Burke, Amber Dakar, Dinesh Kalera, Mathias Korzan, Red Morgan, Maryellen Murphy, Jennifer Newman-Amos, Adam Shafer, Julie Trudeau and Leslie Underwood.

Attention editors and publishers! Money and Markets issues can be republished. Republished issues MUST include attribution of the author(s) and the following short paragraph:

This investment news is brought to you by Money and Markets. Money and Markets is a free daily investment newsletter from Martin D. Weiss and Weiss Research analysts offering the latest investing news and financial insights for the stock market, including tips and advice on investing in gold, energy and oil. Dr. Weiss is a leader in the fields of investing, interest rates, financial safety and economic forecasting. To view archives or subscribe, visit http://www.moneyandmarkets.com.

From time to time, Money and Markets may have information from select third-party advertisers known as “external sponsorships.” We cannot guarantee the accuracy of these ads. In addition, these ads do not necessarily express the viewpoints of Money and Markets or its editors. For more information, see our terms and conditions.

© 2008 by Weiss Research, Inc. All rights reserved.

15430 Endeavour Drive, Jupiter, FL 33478

Share Email
Tweet

Previous post: How far is too far?

Next post: Entry point reached: Reco deadline tomorrow!

  • Sign Up FREE

    To receive your Money and Markets FREE investment newsletter subscription, type in your e-mail address. We respect your privacy

  • Advertising

  • Take advantage of our strong track record for safety to guard your wealth in these trying times with our free daily updates delivered to your inbox every morning.
  • Advertising

  • Market Update

    Click an index for a graph of its recent activity:

    U.S.

    Thu 5/24/12, 5:16pm
    Index Last Change
    DOW
    NASDAQ 2,839 -10.7
    NASDAQ
    S&P 500 1,321 +1.8
    S&P 500

    Europe

    Thu 5/24/12, 11:51am
    Index Last Change
    FTSE 100 5,350 +83.6
    FTSE 100
    CAC 40 3,038 +35.0
    CAC 40
    DAX 6,316 +30.1
    DAX

    Asia

    Fri 5/25/12, 8:01pm
    Index Last Change
    HANG SENG 18,666 +0.0
    HANG SENG
    NIKKEI 225 8,609 +45.9
    NIKKEI 225
    CSI 300 2,595 -21.6
    CSI 300
  • Advertising

  • Weiss Group Press Releases

    Weiss Ratings: U.S. Credit Union Deposits Up $41 Billion in 2011 April 2, 2012
    Weiss Ratings: U.S. Banking Industry Continues Modest Turnaround March 26, 2012
    Weiss Ratings: Southwestern Banks Show Signs of Turnaround January 24, 2012
    Weiss Ratings: Sluggish Demand Triggers Downgrades of China, Canada, Saudi Arabia December 19, 2011
    Weiss Ratings: Eurozone Crisis Prompts Debt Downgrades December 9, 2011
    • Find us on Facebook

    • Follow us on Twitter

      • Money and Markets on Twitter
      • Money and Markets on Twitter
      • Dr Martin D. Weiss on Twitter
      • Nilus Mattive on Twitter
      • Ron Rowland on Twitter
      • Mike Larson on Twitter
      • Jack Crooks on Twitter
    • Weiss Ratings - Top-Rated Banks, Credit-Unions, Insurers

    • Weiss Research Affiliate

    • About Us
    • FAQ
    • Legal
    • Privacy
    • Whitelist
    • Advertising
    • ©2012 Money and Markets. All Rights Reserved.
    Weiss Research, Inc., founded in 1971, has a long history of providing research and analysis designed to empower investors with information and tools to make more informed, independent decisions along with an equally long history of public service. [More »]